Lal:just made it seem 'cheesy' in the film.
Yeah... I'm sure that was the problem 
Anyway, Lal I have read all your arguments and have sat down and thought about it logically for a few hours today in order to forumlate a concise and precise rebuttal with no margin for error or further debate. So here goes...
Lal: Sorry Row...I do have to be point out a few flaws in your argument...
<insert some desperate fan-girl justification here>
bullshit
But seriously, i'm just poking fun cos while I've not read the books I still marvel at the utter craposity of these kinda films and despair at the fact that they are actually popular... whereas genious films like Moon etc get ignored into obscurity.
But having said that, if this scene is in any of the films I will definately go watch them 
(part-time Tailor, reformed DF'er, one-time chicken)
Rowanath Huntaaaar/ Narlonath